H/T NY
Daily News
Without
real Tort Reform Obamacare will cause our Medical System to go bankrupt! We all
know that Trail Lawyers are Obama’s top political donors, so the chance of
Obama pushing for Malpractice Reform will be ZERO!
Obamacare
will fail without tort reform: Malpractice insurance costs are crippling
medicine
Friday,
November 19, 2010, 4:00 AM
I am what
you call a successful neurosurgeon, and I have nothing against "socialized
medicine" as such. Everybody deserves good health care. But I am nonetheless
worried about President Obama's health care reform, because
without tort reform as part of the package, it can't address the labor shortage
we face in my specialty.
Tort reform
is crucial because it would curtail the threat of frivolous malpractice
lawsuits, reward all patients who have been injured by medical mishaps, not
just the wealthy with access to high-powered lawyers - and reduce the anxieties
faced by young doctors going into medicine in the first place, especially those
entering high-stakes fields like my own.
For example,
I just operated on a 60-year old man who didn't even know his surgery was an
emergency. He was losing motor function in his lower extremities due to severe
spinal stenosis, and we were able to move quickly because we were free of
insurance issues. But what if those insurance issues were paramount? What if
somebody like me wasn't available, to anybody, because the supply of
neurosurgeons had dried up - because the costs of letting them operate were too
high? Would he still be walking?
Good doctors
have always been in short supply; why worry especially about neurosurgery?
Only because
spinal problems affect nearly 80% of our aging population: It's one of the most
common reasons patients visit a primary care physician, right behind the yearly
physical, the common cold, prenatal care and anxiety-related disorders. Baby
boomers are about to overwhelm the system with demand for treatment of spinal
problems - including surgery - at precisely the moment the supply of
neurosurgeons able to treat them is dwindling.
How could
this have happened? How could we have a labor shortage in one of the most
lucrative, prestigious and desperately needed medical specialties?
One reason
is the difficulty of getting certified, which makes sense. In May of 2009, the American Board of Neurological
Surgeons certified 59 individuals as capable of tasks required of
their specialty. But only about 30% of them, just 18 people, were ready
to perform the surgeries that might solve the spinal problems of an aging
population. The average age of these people was 37, they all carried loans from
medical school and malpractice insurance premiums they faced were about $4.5
million a year if they settled in this state.
Thus we come
to the second reason: the cost of malpractice insurance, which creates a very
high cost of entry into this field. Unfortunately, the health care reforms of
the Obama administration have done little to curb costs. These costs are
imposed by hospital inefficiencies as unpoliced by government-run insurance
plans and by the price of malpractice insurance undisciplined by tort reform.
I believe
that tort reform is the key to reducing both kinds of cost, because the
malignant threat of malpractice haunts the hospitals as well as the physicians.
Without such reform, the choice for practicing neurosurgeons like me is between
retirement and working 24/7 just to cover my insurance overhead. My premature
retirement will reduce the supply of surgeons capable of dealing with the
spinal problems of an aging population - and that supply is already short and
getting shorter. Meanwhile, a few more board-certified surgeons a year won't
meet the growing demand. The lines at your doctor's office could get long.
When
Congress returns to consider the problem of health care, it must understand
that without tort reform, neurosurgery of the kind I can provide to an aging
population will be unavailable.
Lavyne is
Clinical Professor of Neurological Surgery at Weill Cornell
Medical College of Cornell University in New York City.
Nice post. A good cry out for a malpractice attorney. Keep up.
ReplyDelete